Print ISBN: 978-1-63700-071-7
# of Pages: 300
# of Volumes: 1
Print List Price: $105
e-ISBN: 978-1-63700-072-4
eBook User Price: $105
Free Online Access
Spread the Word

Critical Insights: The Lord of the Rings

Editor: Robert C. Evans
January 2022

J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings quickly became one of the most popular and influential novels of the twentieth century. It inspired not just one film but a series of well-received movies that brought Tolkien’s highly imaginative fantasy epic to life on the big screen. This volume about the novel discusses the work from numerous points of view, employing biographical, historical, cultural, mythic, and aesthetic approaches, among others.

This volume, like all others in the Critical Insights series, is divided into several sections. It begins with an essay titled “The Emotions of a Tolkien Reader” by Franco Manni. This is followed by a Biography of J.R.R. Tolkien written by volume editor Robert C. Evans.

A collection of four critical contexts essays are intended to treat the novel

  • From a historical vantage point
  • In terms of its critical reception
  • Using a specific critical lens
  • And by comparing and contrasting it with another important work.

This section opens with an essay by Nancy Bunting titled, “Speak Memory: Some Biographical Sources of The Lord of the Rings, followed by a piece by Brandon Schneeberger, “Teaching Tolkien: An Overview of Approaches,” This essay provides practical suggestions on teaching Tolkien’s works to make them accessible to a wide variety of students. The following two articles are written by John R. Holmes and Robert C. Evans respectively. The first, “‘The Departure of Boromir”: A Close Reading,” illustrates the benefits of paying close attention to specific textual details when approaching literature. The final essay, “Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings Trilogy and Victor Fleming’s The Wizard of Oz,” compares and contrasts film adaptations of The Lord of the Rings to the classic Wizard of Oz.

Following these four Critical Context essays is the Critical Readings section of this book, which contains the following essays:

  • Reading and Understanding Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings: A Survey of Critical Responses, by Robert C. Evans
  • Tom Shippey on The Lord of the Rings: The Legacy of a Major Tolkien Scholar, by Robert C. Evans
  • Critical Responses to Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings Film Trilogy, by Joyce Ahn
  • Tolkien as a Craftsman: The Literary Value of The Lord of the Rings, by Courtney Petrucci
  • “A Dream of Music”: The Eärendil Poem in The Lord of the Rings, by John R. Holmes
  • Eldest: Tom Bombadil and Fintan mac Bóchra as Memory Keepers, by Kris Swank
  • Shelob’s Origins in Tolkien’s Cats, by Nancy Bunting
  • Religion in Tolkien’s Works, by Franco Manni
  • Pity, Malice, and Agency in Tolkien’s Subcreation, by Matthew M. DeForrest
  • The Power That Dare Not Speak Its Name: Tolkien, Magic, and the Occult, by Matthew M. DeForrest
  • Mythic People of Fire and Tolkien’s Southern Races in The Lord of the Rings, by Larry Swain
  • Tolkien’s Alleged Anti-Semitism and the Diaspora, by Larry Swain

In the final section, Resources, easy-to-follow lists are provided to help guide the reader through important dates and moments in the author’s life. A selection of further reading is then provided. Each essay in Critical Insights: The Lord of the Rings includes a list of Works Cited and detailed endnotes. Also included in this volume is a Chronology of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Life, a list of Additional Works by J.R.R. Tolkien, a Bibliography, biographies of the Editor and Contributors, and an alphabetical Index.

The Critical Insights Series distills the best of both classic and current literary criticism of the world’s most studies literature. Edited and written by some of academia’s most distinguished literary scholars, Critical Insights: The Lord of the Rings provides authoritative, in-depth scholarship that students and researchers will rely on for years. This volume is destined to become a valuable purchase for all.


Libraries and schools purchasing the printed version of any Salem Press title get complimentary online access to that title on our new online database, Combining Salem's Literature, History, Health, Science and Careers titles, students and researchers can now access all of their Salem content in one comprehensive site. Any school or library with print reference content in Salem Press' database is entitled to online access to that content. This access is an inherent part of our product.